Pity the Poor Plebian
It’s not the first time I've felt compelled to write about Big Brother, but I just got a whiff of what troubles me about this latest, particularly twisted strain, of the show.
We dream that we can make sense of this bullshit, that we can we can contextualise the merit and meaning within. We can imagine we’re contributing to an important discourse on popular TV culture whn we reviiew an entire series... and we’ll valiantly critique an individual show for the whore-press, for a coupla hundred quid mate, or our M.A dissertation, for a smidgen of supposed kudos. Or we might cite a particular scene in our coffee break, noting its uncanny parallels with an episode in our house-share, our personnel department, or (very occaisionally, of course) amongst close friends…
But the truly unsettling thing about it lies behind the cover of the sensational. Its exactly that - the ability to cloak itself in mediocrity, whilst ruthlessly persecuting the stupid (and perhaps even the innocent). It, and it's genre siblings, tell us what we really need to know about where our civilisation is at right now. On the eve of Live8, in the midst of debacle that is peace in the middle east... we seem far happier watching ourselves tear each other apart, at close if vicarious quarters, just like in the Colliseum. This episode, moreso than all the variants that preceded it, demonstrates the emptiness of our epoch more astutely than even its heinous producers could have imagined.
The Mikose cider pogrom I saw tonight triggered the realisation that although it might purport to represent a worthwhile, novel, if distorted version of social realities we can all relate to, BB makes one distinction that belies these claims whole (and cold) heartedly. In real life the victims of such cruel and anarchic persecution usually, if not immediately, get an opportunity to face a jury, and more importantly be counselled in some fashion. These fuckers just don't stand a chance in hell.
So lets disregard the fact that I hold no significant respect for any of the specimens presently residing in this house house of cultural detention. My point is that these people are little more than rats in a laboratory – and they only learn the reality of their narciscism, and the lessons of the craving for notoriety, when it's too late and they are removed from the program(me), voted out of the experiment. Nobody is there to adise or debrief them, to console them… they face the prospect of being defined by their actions, and our responses to them, for the rest of their lives. Okay so they didn't have to do it, but that only demonstrates how mediated and mashed-up the contestants perception of their own lives is. And in this regard the grand concept of 'entertainment show' is exposed for what it really is, a fucking freakshow.
We dream that we can make sense of this bullshit, that we can we can contextualise the merit and meaning within. We can imagine we’re contributing to an important discourse on popular TV culture whn we reviiew an entire series... and we’ll valiantly critique an individual show for the whore-press, for a coupla hundred quid mate, or our M.A dissertation, for a smidgen of supposed kudos. Or we might cite a particular scene in our coffee break, noting its uncanny parallels with an episode in our house-share, our personnel department, or (very occaisionally, of course) amongst close friends…
But the truly unsettling thing about it lies behind the cover of the sensational. Its exactly that - the ability to cloak itself in mediocrity, whilst ruthlessly persecuting the stupid (and perhaps even the innocent). It, and it's genre siblings, tell us what we really need to know about where our civilisation is at right now. On the eve of Live8, in the midst of debacle that is peace in the middle east... we seem far happier watching ourselves tear each other apart, at close if vicarious quarters, just like in the Colliseum. This episode, moreso than all the variants that preceded it, demonstrates the emptiness of our epoch more astutely than even its heinous producers could have imagined.
The Mikose cider pogrom I saw tonight triggered the realisation that although it might purport to represent a worthwhile, novel, if distorted version of social realities we can all relate to, BB makes one distinction that belies these claims whole (and cold) heartedly. In real life the victims of such cruel and anarchic persecution usually, if not immediately, get an opportunity to face a jury, and more importantly be counselled in some fashion. These fuckers just don't stand a chance in hell.
So lets disregard the fact that I hold no significant respect for any of the specimens presently residing in this house house of cultural detention. My point is that these people are little more than rats in a laboratory – and they only learn the reality of their narciscism, and the lessons of the craving for notoriety, when it's too late and they are removed from the program(me), voted out of the experiment. Nobody is there to adise or debrief them, to console them… they face the prospect of being defined by their actions, and our responses to them, for the rest of their lives. Okay so they didn't have to do it, but that only demonstrates how mediated and mashed-up the contestants perception of their own lives is. And in this regard the grand concept of 'entertainment show' is exposed for what it really is, a fucking freakshow.